President Donald Trump signed an executive order late on Friday 20 November that directs federal contractors and subcontractors to consult the White House about congressional requests for information and to withhold communications the White House considers privileged, according to the Associated Press, ABC News and Fox News.

What the order requires

  • Consultation and withholding (AP, via NBC and CBS): contractors and subcontractors must “consult with his administration about inquiries they receive from Congress”, coordinate with the White House and agencies on “appropriate responses”, and withhold “any communications that the White House considers privileged”.
  • Notification (ABC News): contractors must “immediately notify the White House and their contracting agencies of ‘any pending or future congressional request respecting the contractors’ communications or work with the executive branch’”, ABC reports, quoting the order. The Office of Management and Budget is to develop guidelines for compliance and “adequate coordination”.
  • Penalties: the AP says contracts could be terminated and future work suspended; ABC adds suspension or debarment from future federal contracts.
  • Scope: the AP says the order applies to all contractors and subcontractors, “tens of thousands of businesses”. ABC cites Bloomberg Government for roughly 100,000 companies holding federal contracts, plus subcontractors.
  • Stated rationale: ABC quotes the order as saying “The ability of the Congress to seek executive branch information is limited” and that Congress cannot seek it “without a valid legislative purpose that does not intrude on core Executive functions”. The AP quotes the White House fact sheet as describing the order as “protecting executive privileges from congressional overreach” and as saying congressional leaders have tried to intrude by “harassing private companies that contract with the federal government”.

The related agency directive and reactions

  • Directive to agencies: the AP reports that Will Scharf, identified in coverage as White House Counsel, told federal agencies on Monday that they must seek approval from his office and the Office of Legislative Affairs before agreeing to appear before Congress. ABC says it obtained the memo on Monday and that it requires “explicit permission from the White House” before employees testify.
  • Scharf and Garcia: the AP says Scharf wrote to Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, suggesting some investigations “may amount to ‘blatant criminality’”. Garcia called the order a “blatant attack on Congress’ constitutional right to conduct oversight” and said “we’re just getting started” (AP). ABC quotes Garcia as saying Congress “has wide latitude to conduct investigations and oversight” and “will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized DOJ”.
  • Legal questions: Fox News says the order “could invite legal challenges, particularly if contractors are told to withhold records sought by subpoena”. That is Fox’s own statement; the pages Lens read name no legal expert, no company or trade-group response and no lawsuit.

Where reports differ

  • Number of companies: “tens of thousands” (AP) against roughly 100,000 plus subcontractors (ABC, citing Bloomberg Government).
  • Penalties: termination and suspension (AP), loss of existing contracts or suspension (Fox), and suspension or debarment (ABC).
  • “Immediately” and OMB guidance: these appear only in the ABC account.
  • Who is notified: “consult with his administration” (AP), the White House (Fox), the White House and contracting agencies (ABC).
  • Garcia’s role: “top Democrat” on House Oversight (AP), “incoming” chair (ABC), and “likely” next chair (Fox).
  • The Scharf memo: the AP adds the Office of Legislative Affairs; ABC says “explicit permission from the White House”; Fox says agencies must clear employee testimony with the administration first.
  • A quote not found: search summaries attributed “unprecedented and blatantly unlawful” to Rep. Jamie Raskin; none of the pages Lens read carry it, so it is not included.

Sources and notes

Lens read NBC News (AP, 21 November), CBS News (AP, 21 November), Fox News (21 November; Lens read the verbatim text only to about 40,000 of 65,000 characters) and ABC News via Good Morning America (21 November). The Hill returned an access error, and CNN, The Washington Post and Bloomberg were not read. No page gives the order’s title or a calendar date beyond “late Friday”, and Lens did not open the order text on whitehouse.gov.

Image: File photo of the White House north facade, 2007, by Ad Meskens, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.